Schedule
Theories of Scientific Explanation
Sessions 1–5 · Weeks 1–3-
Introduction: Theories of explanation
Woodward, "Scientific Explanation" (SEP) -
Statistical relevance model
Salmon, "Statistical Explanation" (1971), §§1–3, 7–8. Skim §13.Hempel & Oppenheim, "Studies in the Logic of Explanation" (1948) -
Unificationist model
Friedman, "Explanation and Scientific Understanding" (1974) -
Pragmatics of explanation
van Fraassen, "The Pragmatics of Explanation" (1980) -
The interventionist account of explanation
Woodward, "Explanation, Invariance, and Intervention" (1997)Woodward, "Interventionist Theories of Causation in Psychological Perspective" (2007)
Cognitive Science of Explanation
Sessions 6–12 · Weeks 3–6-
Causal explanation in cognition
Lombrozo, "Simplicity and Probability in Causal Explanation" (2007)Lombrozo & Vasilyeva, "Causal Explanation" (2017) -
The causal hierarchy
Bareinboim et al., "On Pearl's Hierarchy and the Foundations of Causal Inference" (2022), READ ONLY §§1.1–1.3. OPTIONAL ADDITION: §§1.4–1.5. -
Actual causation
Halpern & Pearl, "Causes and Explanations" (2005)Halpern, Actual Causality Ch. 1–2 -
Causal selection & normality
Icard, Kominsky & Knobe, "Normality and Actual Causal Strength" (2017) -
Counterfactual effect sizes
Quillien & Lucas, "Counterfactuals and the Logic of Causal Selection" (2023). Read up to the end of study 2; you may also skip the "Reanalysis of existing data" section in the introduction.Quillien & Barlev, "Causal Judgment in the Wild: Evidence from the 2020 U.S. Presidential Election" (2022) -
Pragmatics & communication
Kirfel, Icard & Gerstenberg, "Inference from Explanation" (2022) -
Communication-first explanation
Harding, Gerstenberg & Icard, "A Communication-First Account of Explanation" (2025). Focus on sections 1, 2.3, 3, 4.1, 4.4, and 5 (≈19 pages). Sections 2.1–2.2 recap material from earlier sessions (Hempel/Salmon, Woodward); skim only if you want a refresher. Sections 4.2, 4.3, and 4.5 apply the model to additional explanatory virtues — optional.
Interpretable AI
Sessions 13–17 · Weeks 7–9-
Foundations of interpretable AI
Erasmus, Brunet & Fisher, "What Is Interpretability?" (2021). Focus on §1, §2.2, §3, and §4.1–§4.3 (≈12 pages). -
Local model-agnostic explanations (LIME)
Ribeiro, Singh & Guestrin, "Why Should I Trust You?: Explaining the Predictions of Any Classifier" (2016). -
Feature attribution methods
Lundberg & Lee, "A Unified Approach to Interpreting Model Predictions" (SHAP) (2017).Note: The paper is mostly heavy on technicalities. As an introduction you can read and reaction post instead through Hart, "Shapley Value" (The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, 2nd ed., 2008), instead which talks about Shapley values in general — not just in xAI — although the course will focus on the AI application. -
Causal abstraction & mechanistic interpretability
Geiger, Lu, Icard & Potts, "Causal Abstractions of Neural Networks" (2021) — listed here as the conceptual scaffold for the session; this is not the paper I recommend you read.Please read this one instead: Ameisen et al. (Anthropic, 2025), "Circuit Tracing: Revealing Computational Graphs in Language Models" — sections 1–3 only (Introduction, Building an Interpretable Replacement Model, Attribution Graphs). -
Memorial Day — No class
-
Causal mechanisms in LLMs
Refresher: quickly skim sections 1–3 of Ameisen et al. (Anthropic, 2025), "Circuit Tracing: Revealing Computational Graphs in Language Models" (the Session 16 reading) for context then read just the short section "Chain-of-thought Faithfulness" (≈3 pages) from the companion paper to this one at: Lindsey et al. (Anthropic, 2025), "On the Biology of a Large Language Model"Optionally, you can also read the section "Uncovering Hidden Goals in a Misaligned Model" immediately following this one in the same paper.
Student Presentations
Sessions 18–19 · Week 10-
Student presentations I
-
Student presentations II
General information
What to expect?
What you can expect from me
I will …
- Provide an introduction and context for the papers discussed during the seminar
- Facilitate class discussions
- Provide feedback on final papers
- Be available during office hours
What I expect from you
You will …
- Attend class and participate in discussions
- Lead one discussion session
- Submit reaction posts (due 8 PM before class)
- Write a final paper
- Present your work in Sessions 18–19
Grading
- 1/3class participation
- 1/3reaction posts
- 1/3final paper
Reaction posts
Reaction posts should be submitted by 8 PM the night before class. They should be 1–2 paragraphs and engage critically with the assigned readings. You should express your opinion rather than summarize the contents of the paper. You may raise questions, identify connections to other material, or offer a brief argument.
Final paper
The final paper should be 1000–2000 words and engage substantively with topics covered in the course. It may be one of the following three:
- An empirical project proposal (can include computational modelling projects)
- A literature review based on one of the class topics
- A theoretical essay
You will also be expected to give a short presentation of your project during the last two sessions of the course, which will be part of the grading for the final paper.
Policies
Please familiarize yourself with Stanford’s honor code. We will adhere to it and follow through on its penalty guidelines.
Access and accommodations
Stanford is committed to providing equal educational opportunities for disabled students. Disabled students are a valued and essential part of the Stanford community. We welcome you to our class. If you experience disability, please register with the Office of Accessible Education (OAE). Professional staff will evaluate your needs, support appropriate and reasonable accommodations, and prepare an Academic Accommodation Letter for faculty. To get started, or to re-initiate services, please visit oae.stanford.edu. If you already have an Academic Accommodation Letter, we invite you to share your letter with us. Academic Accommodation Letters should be shared at the earliest possible opportunity so we may partner with you and OAE to identify any barriers to access and inclusion that might be encountered in your experience of this course.
